Microsoft’s Xbox One Reveal

On May 21st, Microsoft finally revealed their next-generation console. I, for one, expected that these 3 months between PS4 and the Xbox One’s reveals would be precious time for Microsoft to make some improvements and match the competition. But, if they did make improvements… I don’t want to think how bad it must have been before.

Xbox One Logo

Just like for the PS4 reveal, I have prepared a bullet-point summary of the most important stuff.

Xbox One Conference

  • The goal of the next Xbox is to make a device aimed at not only games, but also television and software
  • The name is revealed – Xbox One
  • Voice input and gesture controls can be used to control the Xbox One
  • “Two screen mode” – you can use a browser on a separate window while watching TV
  • You can tell the console which channel or show you want to watch and it’ll switch to it. Wee!
  • Xbox One can also detect your heartbeat
  • Controller shown – a lot like the Xbox 360 controller, though they say the D-pad is supposedly better
  • EA Sports segment – FIFA, Madden, NBA Live, UFC games will be released in the next 12 months
  • Supposedly, you’ll also be able to use your hands and feet to play sports games
  • Forza Motorsport 5 announced – launch game
  • New IP called Quantum Break, featuring a child with superpowers shown
  • 8 new franchises will be released within the first year of Xbox One’s life, out of 15 Microsoft Studios games in total
  • Upcoming Halo TV show announced (not kidding). Steven Spielberg will work on it
  • Xbox One to be launched by the end of the year
  • World premiere for Call of Duty: Ghost. Timed exclusive for Xbox One. It will feature dogs

Xbox One Console Controller Kinect

And that was it… Literally. Fortunately, we learned some other, more important (but only helping shape the sad picture) points afterwards:

  • Xbox One will not require a constant online connection
  • Used games will not be blocked
  • “If you’re backwards compatable, you’re really backwards” – Don Mattrick… lol – apparently, neither disc games, nor XBLA purchases will be playable on the One
  • Reason for the above is the Xbox One running x86 architecture – seems they took a cue from Sony here
  • Kinect will be bundled and REQUIRED to use the console
  • Gamerscore from the Xbox 360 will, however, be transferrable to Xbox One
  • 100 friend limit on Xbox Live raised to 1000 on the One
  • Via the upcoming cloud service, developers will be able to alter achievements depending on players’ response to their games
  • Two operating systems will run side-by-side – Xbox OS for the games and Windows 8-based OS for the apps and TV

Finally, here are some specs:

Xbox One Specs

The conference was a total flop, they mostly talked about TV and much less about games. And what were the games? Forza, EA Sports games, Call of Duty… Seriously? Halo TV show? Even with Spielberg on board, it’ll be hard to make it good. The only glimmer of hope was the promise of 8 whopping new franchises in the first year – pretty nice. But it was far too little to save the conference. Only later did we find out some more important details.

No “always on” and not blocking used games is probably the best thing to come out of this all, debunking the darkest rumours. However, the fact that they also claimed you can install the game and then play without the disc still leaves the question open – if that worked without any further quirks, that would allow you to share your disc with everyone to copy the game. So definitely expect a new rabbit out of the hat here.

Other than that, there was aboslutely nothing promising – required Kinect, no backwards compatibility even with XBLA titles (they could’ve one-upped Sony here). The positive things were not very important, like retaining your Gamerscore… Big deal.

Specs seem comparable to the PS4 at first glance… But there are two important details here:

  1. The system memory is 8 GB of DDR3 RAM, which is not nearly as fast as PS4’s DDR5 (68 vs. 176 GB/s)
  2. X86 architecture means it’ll be just as easy for developers to use as the PS4, right? Wrong. Xbox One will also feature embedded memory of 32 MB, which will be quite fast at 102 GB/s (still quite a bit lower than Sony’s DDR5) – meaning developers will need to use both it and the main RAM, whereas PS4 just has the RAM as the only memory they need to look after

Xbox One Ports

It’s also funny, yet inevitable they had to have a Blu-ray drive on the Xbox One, Sony’s proprietary format. There were rumours, along with the “always on” thing, that everything would be stored on the hard drive, but it’s one generation too early for consoles to give up on optical media.

The substantial jump of Sony’s stocks right after the Xbox One reveal speaks more than anything else. Unless they turn the tides dramatically at E3, Microsoft are headed towards a disaster of Wii U proportions, if not worse!

EDIT: Today (May 24th), a very convincing rumour has surfaced claiming that Microsoft will enforce a policy where only certified retailers will be able to sell you used games, and, by selling a game to them, the selling owner gets erased as owner in Microsoft’s Azure cloud system, and then, when it’s bought, the buyer can register the game as his own (which would require internet connection, unless he can do it directly at the store). The stores willing to take part in that must agree to give Microsoft and publishers a slice of the profit – that means reduced profit for the likes of GameStop and the publishers finally getting some money on used sales.

And what about buying off the original owner, as opposed to getting ripped off at a store? I can only imagine that that’s what the used games fee would be used for – if you want to register the game as your own without going through an approved retailer. What would that do to borrowing from a friend?… I guess it would not be possible anymore. What does it mean for rentals? I suppose GameFly or whoever you’re renting from would just have to wipe the owner every time the game is returned – but I suppose they’d also need to pay a fee to Microsoft/publishers for that.

All in all, this is a very dangerous idea – it could lure publishers into making big hits exclusive to the One so that they get some money on used sales. Sony might panic and copy/paste this crap. In the end, the gamer gets utterly screwed. But, for now, it only reaffirms that One will be lame and not worth buying.

Xbox One TV

EDIT 2: Even more news coming today, Microsoft filed a patent for TV achievements… I imagine things like watching every episode of a show, NOT changing the channel during commercials, stuff like that. In short, I find it quite unsettling because I realise what a clever idea this is. It’ll work, and it’ll make people willing to do stuff they wouldn’t normally do just to get the achievements…

Wanna hit the bar on Friday night?
Nah, last episode of 24 will be on, I gotta get that achievement!

How far are we from the life achievements and, respectively, being monitored at every single step we make? Scary stuff…


1 comment

  1. Firion
    Firion May 23, 2013 1:30 am  Reply

    As I’ve been saying everywhere to everyone this (IMO) looks like shit. It was 90% tv sports and dog. And the company is contradicting itself with the VP saying you’ll have to connect once a day and pay a fee for used games and xbox support saying that’s not the case, and now saying wait for E3 like it excuses the horrible conference

    I think they’re judging peoples reactions and going from there, but if these two points are true then I’m done with them period, and I think they won’t do well. if so

    The fact you have to have a kinect to use the xbox is dumb too, the thing no one liked is back to stay. I held out a little hope since I was a huge fan of the Original Xbox and I started off a fan of the 360 but MS seems content with doing Anti consumerism bullshit which I won’t stand for

    Also Xbox One is the dumbest name ever, I get what they’re going for but there was already a Xbox one, They don’t seem to know how to count

    Xbox-Xbox 360-Xbox One

    Unless they come out and say for sure no online is required and they won’t block used games in anyway, AND have LOTS of amazing exclusives then I’m done with them. Even then I don’t like the dumb always on kinect

    I’m leaning pretty far PS4 right now considering the Wii U doesn’t have any games to make it worth getting and it’s already outdated, the Xbox has it’s anti consumerism bullshit and PCs are just too expensive for me.

    We’ll see though, there’s still a very small chance they could salvage themselves

Leave a Reply to Firion Cancel reply